Shelly Plus 2PM vs. Shelly 2.5

MiLykie

Hi Everybody,

I have successfully Shelly'd a number of roller shutters with Shelly 2.5. Work like a charm, both from the app and from the old-school button.

Recently I've got Shelly Plus 2PM, as a supposedly newer evolution of the kind. I switched device profile to "cover", and the rollers fine ok from the app. However, the issue is that with the wall buttons (which are exactly the same as the other) I am unable to switch direction.

Namely, when both buttons are set to "off" I can select any direction. But when one of the buttons is set to on, let's say down, if I switch to up, the shutter stands still. When I switch back to down, it still stands still.

I have moved the Shelly 2.5 that works fine to this new location, and with 2.5 it works as expected - I can switch up and down as I please. With Plus 2PM I have to switch to neutral, wait and then switch in the desired direction. It seems to me like Plus 2PM switches inputs too quicky, and both are "on" for a short while, which blocks the shutter.

Is there any settings I should specifically change/adapt, await firmware update, or just toss 2PM and get 2.5?

Thanks!

MiLykie

Shelly Plus 2PM runs: 20230718-125047/1.0.0-beta6-g4893033

Shelly 2.5 runs: 20230503-095750/v1.13.0-g9aed950

thgoebel

Welcome to the forum!

To your issue: Please call the configuration data from Shelly plus 2PM with command

Code

http://<ip-of-Shelly/rpc/shelly.getconfig

and from Shelly 2.5 with command

Code

http://<ip-of-Shelly>/settings

and post both strings here. Many thanks!

MiLykie

Thanks, those are the configs:

For Shelly 2.5:

Code

device    
type    "SHSW-25"
mac    "C45BBE771103"
hostname    "shellyswitch25-C45BBE771103"
num_outputs    2
num_meters    2
num_rollers    1
mode    "roller"
wifi_ap    
enabled    false
ssid    "shellyswitch25-C45BBE771103"
key    ""
wifi_sta    
enabled    true
ssid    "WIFI NAME1"
ipv4_method    "dhcp"
ip    null
gw    null
mask    null
dns    null
wifi_sta1    
enabled    true
ssid    "WIFI NAME1"
ipv4_method    "dhcp"
ip    null
gw    null
mask    null
dns    null
ap_roaming    
enabled    true
threshold    -70
mqtt    
enable    false
server    "192.168.33.3:1883"
user    ""
id    "shellyswitch25-C45BBE771103"
reconnect_timeout_max    60
reconnect_timeout_min    2
clean_session    true
keep_alive    60
max_qos    0
retain    false
update_period    30
coiot    
enabled    true
update_period    15
peer    ""
sntp    
server    "time.google.com"
enabled    true
login    
enabled    false
unprotected    false
username    "admin"
pin_code    ""
name    "ShellyR #1"
fw    "20230503-095750/v1.13.0-g9aed950"
factory_reset_from_switch    true
discoverable    false
build_info    
build_id    "20230503-095750/v1.13.0-g9aed950"
build_timestamp    "2023-05-03T09:57:50Z"
build_version    "1.0"
cloud    
enabled    true
connected    true
timezone    "Europe/Madrid"
lat    35.000000
lng    -0.114699
tzautodetect    false
tz_utc_offset    7200
tz_dst    false
tz_dst_auto    true
time    "10:24"
unixtime    1691310269
led_status_disable    false
debug_enable    false
allow_cross_origin    false
actions    
active    false
names    
0    "btn_on_url"
1    "btn_off_url"
2    "longpush_url"
3    "shortpush_url"
4    "out_on_url"
5    "out_off_url"
6    "btn_on_url"
7    "btn_off_url"
8    "longpush_url"
9    "shortpush_url"
10    "out_on_url"
11    "out_off_url"
12    "roller_open_url"
13    "roller_close_url"
14    "roller_stop_url"
hwinfo    
hw_revision    "prod-191217"
batch_id    1
mode    "roller"
max_power    1840
longpush_time    800
relays    
0    
name    null
appliance_type    "General"
ison    false
has_timer    false
default_state    "switch"
btn_type    "toggle"
btn_reverse    0
auto_on    0
auto_off    0
max_power    0
schedule    false
schedule_rules    []
1    
name    null
appliance_type    "General"
ison    false
has_timer    false
default_state    "switch"
btn_type    "toggle"
btn_reverse    0
auto_on    0
auto_off    0
max_power    0
schedule    false
schedule_rules    []
rollers    
0    
maxtime    20
maxtime_open    30
maxtime_close    30
default_state    "stop"
swap    false
swap_inputs    false
input_mode    "openclose"
button_type    "momentary"
btn_reverse    0
state    "stop"
power    0
is_valid    true
safety_switch    false
schedule    true
schedule_rules    
0    "0230asr-0123456-open"
1    "0000ass-0123456-close"
obstacle_mode    "disabled"
obstacle_action    "stop"
obstacle_power    200
obstacle_delay    1
ends_delay    2500
safety_mode    "while_opening"
safety_action    "stop"
safety_allowed_on_trigger    "none"
off_power    2
positioning    true
favorites_enabled    false
favorites    
0    
name    "Position 1"
pos    0
1    
name    "Position 2"
pos    0
2    
name    "Position 3"
pos    0
3    
name    "Position 4"
pos    0
eco_mode_enabled    true

Alles anzeigen

And for Shelly Plus 2PM

Code

ble    
enable    false
rpc    
enable    true
observer    
enable    false
cloud    
enable    true
server    "shelly-55-eu.shelly.cloud:6022/jrpc"
cover:0    
id    0
name    null
motor    
idle_power_thr    2
idle_confirm_period    0.5
maxtime_open    60
maxtime_close    60
initial_state    "stopped"
invert_directions    false
in_mode    "dual"
swap_inputs    false
safety_switch    
enable    false
direction    "both"
action    "stop"
allowed_move    null
power_limit    2800
voltage_limit    280
undervoltage_limit    0
current_limit    10
obstruction_detection    
enable    false
direction    "both"
action    "stop"
power_thr    146
holdoff    1
input:0    
id    0
name    null
type    "switch"
invert    false
factory_reset    true
input:1    
id    1
name    null
type    "switch"
invert    false
factory_reset    true
mqtt    
enable    false
server    null
client_id    "shellyplus2pm-441793ceecf4"
user    null
topic_prefix    "shellyplus2pm-441793ceecf4"
rpc_ntf    true
status_ntf    false
use_client_cert    false
enable_rpc    true
enable_control    true
sys    
device    
name    "ShellyRS #3"
mac    "441793CEECF4"
fw_id    "20230718-125047/1.0.0-beta6-g4893033"
discoverable    true
eco_mode    false
profile    "cover"
addon_type    null
location    
tz    "Europe/Madrid"
lat    35.000000
lon    -0.100000
debug    
level    2
file_level    null
mqtt    
enable    false
websocket    
enable    false
udp    
addr    null
ui_data    {}
rpc_udp    
dst_addr    null
listen_port    null
sntp    
server    "time.google.com"
cfg_rev    18
wifi    
ap    
ssid    "ShellyPlus2PM-441793CEECF4"
is_open    true
enable    false
range_extender    
enable    false
sta    
ssid    "WIFI NAME1"
is_open    false
enable    true
ipv4mode    "dhcp"
ip    null
netmask    null
gw    null
nameserver    null
sta1    
ssid    "WIFI NAME2"
is_open    false
enable    true
ipv4mode    "dhcp"
ip    null
netmask    null
gw    null
nameserver    null
roam    
rssi_thr    -80
interval    60
ws    
enable    false
server    null
ssl_ca    "ca.pem"

Alles anzeigen

thgoebel

Thanks for the configuration data! Obviously, you’ve set the input type to “switch” at your Shelly plus 2PM. Please try to set input type “button”:

Der Inhalt kann nicht angezeigt werden, da Sie keine Berechtigung haben, diesen Inhalt zu sehen.

(Menue “settings” at Home Screen)

MiLykie

Thank you, yes, that did the trick!

However, I am still not able to reproduce the control that I have with another 2.5 - namely, ability to stop movement by switching back to neutral (both buttons). It allows to set intermediate positions with just old-style buttons.

Does 2PM Plus support "momentary" type of switch?

Code

device    
type    "SHSW-25"
mac    "C45BBE770844"
hostname    "shellyswitch25-C45BBE770844"
num_outputs    2
num_meters    2
num_rollers    1
mode    "roller"
wifi_ap    
enabled    false
ssid    "shellyswitch25-C45BBE770844"
key    ""
wifi_sta    
enabled    true
ssid    "WIFI NAME1"
ipv4_method    "dhcp"
ip    null
gw    null
mask    null
dns    null
wifi_sta1    
enabled    true
ssid    "WIFI NAME2"
ipv4_method    "dhcp"
ip    null
gw    null
mask    null
dns    null
ap_roaming    
enabled    true
threshold    -70
mqtt    
enable    false
server    "192.168.33.3:1883"
user    ""
id    "shellyswitch25-C45BBE770844"
reconnect_timeout_max    60
reconnect_timeout_min    2
clean_session    true
keep_alive    60
max_qos    0
retain    false
update_period    30
coiot    
enabled    true
update_period    15
peer    ""
sntp    
server    "time.google.com"
enabled    true
login    
enabled    false
unprotected    false
username    "admin"
pin_code    ""
name    "ShellyR #2"
fw    "20230503-095750/v1.13.0-g9aed950"
factory_reset_from_switch    true
discoverable    false
build_info    
build_id    "20230503-095750/v1.13.0-g9aed950"
build_timestamp    "2023-05-03T09:57:50Z"
build_version    "1.0"
cloud    
enabled    true
connected    true
timezone    "Europe/Madrid"
lat    35.000000
lng    -0.200000
tzautodetect    false
tz_utc_offset    7200
tz_dst    false
tz_dst_auto    true
time    "17:35"
unixtime    1691336107
led_status_disable    false
debug_enable    false
allow_cross_origin    false
actions    
active    false
names    
0    "btn_on_url"
1    "btn_off_url"
2    "longpush_url"
3    "shortpush_url"
4    "out_on_url"
5    "out_off_url"
6    "btn_on_url"
7    "btn_off_url"
8    "longpush_url"
9    "shortpush_url"
10    "out_on_url"
11    "out_off_url"
12    "roller_open_url"
13    "roller_close_url"
14    "roller_stop_url"
hwinfo    
hw_revision    "prod-191217"
batch_id    1
mode    "roller"
max_power    1840
longpush_time    800
relays    
0    
name    null
appliance_type    "General"
ison    false
has_timer    false
default_state    "switch"
btn_type    "toggle"
btn_reverse    0
auto_on    0
auto_off    0
max_power    0
schedule    false
schedule_rules    []
1    
name    null
appliance_type    "General"
ison    false
has_timer    false
default_state    "switch"
btn_type    "toggle"
btn_reverse    0
auto_on    0
auto_off    0
max_power    0
schedule    false
schedule_rules    []
rollers    
0    
maxtime    20
maxtime_open    21
maxtime_close    20
default_state    "stop"
swap    false
swap_inputs    false
input_mode    "openclose"
button_type    "momentary"
btn_reverse    0
state    "stop"
power    0
is_valid    true
safety_switch    false
schedule    false
schedule_rules    
0    "0000asr-0123456-open"
obstacle_mode    "disabled"
obstacle_action    "stop"
obstacle_power    200
obstacle_delay    1
ends_delay    2500
safety_mode    "while_opening"
safety_action    "stop"
safety_allowed_on_trigger    "none"
off_power    2
positioning    true
favorites_enabled    true
favorites    
0    
name    "Day"
pos    78
1    
name    "Position 2"
pos    0
2    
name    "Position 3"
pos    0
3    
name    "Position 4"
pos    0
eco_mode_enabled    true

Alles anzeigen

Shelly Plus 2PM vs. Shelly 2.5

Ähnliche Themen

Shelly 2.5 Plus Add On Temp Sensor not found

Shelly 2PM Plus Cover for Garage - Auto Close after n Minutes

Shelly Plus 2Pm + Biticino Matix AM5052 to control a rolling shutter.

Shelly Plus 2PM to monitor power socket (no neutral?)

Shelly plus 2PM position lost

Replacing Finder 20.28 with Shelly Plus 2PM wiring question